RFP for Digital Marketing Services: What Agencies Want to See

An RFP for digital marketing services is a formal document that invites agencies to propose how they would handle your marketing, at what cost, and why they are the right fit. Done well, it filters out the wrong agencies quickly and gives the right ones enough context to respond with something genuinely useful. Done poorly, it wastes everyone’s time and produces a shortlist of polished decks that tell you almost nothing.

Most RFPs sit closer to the second category than the first. That is not because procurement teams are incompetent. It is because the format rewards presentation over substance, and most briefs are written to protect the buyer rather than to elicit honest responses.

I have been on both sides of this process more times than I can count. Running agencies, I have scored inbound RFPs and made a call within ten minutes on whether the opportunity was worth pursuing. As a client-side operator, I have written briefs, reviewed responses, and sat through enough pitch presentations to know exactly where the process breaks down. What follows is a clear-eyed look at how to run an RFP for digital marketing services that actually produces the outcome you need.

Why Most Digital Marketing RFPs Fail Before They Start

The failure mode is almost always the same. A procurement team or marketing director decides they need a new agency. Someone pulls a template from a previous tender, updates the company name and dates, and sends it out. The document is thorough in all the wrong places: pages on company background, supplier diversity policies, data security requirements. But it is vague on the things that actually matter, what you are trying to achieve commercially, what you have tried before, what budget you are working with, and what success looks like in twelve months.

Agencies receive this and face a choice. Invest significant time in a speculative response based on very little information, or pass. The better agencies, the ones with full pipelines and strong reputations, often pass. The ones who respond enthusiastically to vague briefs are frequently the ones with capacity to spare, which is a data point worth noting.

I remember reviewing an RFP at one agency I ran that was 34 pages long. It covered everything from our ISO certification status to our policy on modern slavery. It had exactly one sentence about what the company wanted to achieve with its digital marketing. We passed. The brief told us more about the company’s procurement culture than it did about the marketing opportunity, and what it told us was not encouraging.

If you are thinking about agency models more broadly before writing your RFP, it helps to understand the full range of what agencies actually offer. The Agency Growth & Sales hub covers the commercial and operational dimensions of working with agencies, from selection through to performance management.

What to Include in an RFP for Digital Marketing Services

A well-constructed RFP has six components. Most documents include three of them. The missing three are usually the most important.

1. Company and commercial context

Not boilerplate about when the company was founded. Actual commercial context: what market you operate in, who your customers are, what your competitive position looks like, and what is happening in the business that makes this marketing investment timely. Agencies who understand your commercial situation can propose strategies that are relevant to it. Agencies who do not will default to generic frameworks dressed up in your brand colours.

2. Scope of services required

Be specific about what you are asking for. Paid search, SEO, paid social, content, email, analytics, creative, all of the above? If you are not sure, say so and ask agencies to recommend a scope based on your objectives. Vagueness here produces wildly inconsistent proposals that are almost impossible to compare. The Semrush breakdown of digital marketing agency services is a useful reference if you are mapping scope and want a clear taxonomy of what agencies typically offer.

It is also worth being honest about whether you want a specialist or a generalist. A full-service marketing agency brings breadth and integration. A specialist brings depth in one channel. Neither is universally better. The right answer depends on your situation, your internal capability, and how much coordination overhead you can absorb.

3. Budget range

This is the one that makes procurement teams nervous. The logic for withholding budget is that it gives you negotiating leverage. In practice, it mostly produces proposals that are either wildly over or under what you can actually spend, and it signals to experienced agencies that the process may not be run in good faith.

You do not need to give a precise number. A range is fine. But “budget dependent on proposals received” is not a range, it is an evasion, and good agencies will treat it as such. If you genuinely do not have a budget set, that is a different problem and one worth solving before you issue an RFP.

4. Objectives and success metrics

What does success look like at 6 months and 12 months? Not “improved brand awareness” or “better digital presence.” Actual metrics: cost per acquisition, revenue from organic search, qualified leads per month, return on ad spend. If you cannot articulate what success looks like, agencies will define it for you, and they will naturally define it in ways that favour their own strengths.

Having judged the Effie Awards, I have seen hundreds of cases where the stated objective and the actual business outcome were completely disconnected. The campaigns that win on effectiveness are the ones where the brief was commercially grounded from the start. The same principle applies here.

5. Current state and history

What have you tried before? What worked and what did not? What agency relationships have you had, and why are you looking to change? This context is enormously useful for agencies who are trying to build a genuinely differentiated proposal. Without it, they are guessing. And most of them will guess in the direction of whatever they sold to their last client.

6. Process, timeline, and evaluation criteria

How many agencies are you approaching? What is the timeline from submission to decision? How will you evaluate responses, and what weight are you giving to each criterion? Transparency here is not a weakness. It helps agencies decide whether to invest time in your process and calibrate their response accordingly.

How Agencies Score Your RFP Internally

Most agencies with a functioning new business operation run some version of an opportunity scoring process. They assess the likely revenue, the probability of winning, the cost of pitching, and the strategic fit. A vague or poorly structured RFP scores badly on probability and strategic fit almost by definition, because there is not enough information to assess either.

When I was running a performance marketing agency, we had a simple rule: if we could not identify a clear commercial problem we were being asked to solve, we did not pitch. Not out of arrogance, but because vague briefs produce vague strategies, and vague strategies produce disappointing results, which is bad for both parties. The agencies most likely to pitch on a vague brief are the ones with nothing to lose by doing so.

Buffer has a useful perspective on how social media agencies operate and position themselves, which gives some insight into how agencies think about client fit and opportunity qualification from their side of the table.

One thing worth considering: if you are asking agencies to pitch for a retained engagement, be clear about the engagement model you have in mind. An inbound marketing retainer operates very differently from a project-based scope or a performance-linked arrangement. The pricing, resourcing, and risk profile are all different, and agencies need to know which model they are proposing against.

Structuring the RFP Process: Timelines and Stages

A well-run RFP process has three stages. A credentials review, a written proposal stage, and a presentation or chemistry meeting. Trying to compress all of this into a single submission round usually produces worse outcomes, because it forces agencies to pitch blind without the opportunity to ask questions or clarify the brief.

The credentials review narrows a long list to a shortlist of three to five agencies. The written proposal stage gives those agencies the opportunity to respond in depth. The presentation stage lets you assess the team, the thinking, and the working relationship. Each stage serves a different purpose, and conflating them produces a process that is neither efficient nor effective.

On timelines: give agencies at least two weeks to respond to a written brief, preferably three. A week is not enough for a serious proposal. If your internal timeline does not allow for that, you may need to reconsider whether a formal RFP is the right process for this hire, or whether a more direct approach to two or three known agencies would serve you better.

One thing I would always recommend: hold a briefing call or Q&A session after the RFP is issued. Give all shortlisted agencies the chance to ask questions, and share the answers with all of them. This levels the playing field, surfaces ambiguities in your brief, and produces better responses. The questions agencies ask in that session are also a useful early signal of how they think.

Evaluating Responses Without Being Fooled by Presentation

Pitch decks are a performance. The best agencies at pitching are not always the best agencies at doing the work, and the correlation between the two is weaker than most buyers assume. I have seen spectacularly produced pitch decks from agencies that were mediocre operators, and I have seen scrappy, direct proposals from teams that went on to deliver exceptional results.

The things worth evaluating in a written response are the quality of the strategic thinking, the specificity of the proposed approach, the evidence of relevant experience, and the credibility of the proposed team. Not the production quality of the document, the number of case studies, or how enthusiastically they describe your brand as “exciting.”

Ask agencies to show their working. Not just what they would do, but why. What assumptions are they making about your market? What would they test first and why? What would change their approach if the initial data told a different story? These questions separate agencies who are thinking from agencies who are templating.

Pricing is worth scrutinising carefully, but not in isolation. An agency that comes in 30% cheaper than the others is either more efficient, making different assumptions about scope, or planning to make up the difference through change requests. Find out which before you let price drive the decision. The accounting dynamics of a marketing agency are worth understanding as a buyer, because they explain a lot about how agencies price, where margin lives, and what happens when a contract is underpriced from the start.

Sector-Specific Considerations for Digital Marketing RFPs

Not all digital marketing RFPs are the same. The considerations for a B2B technology company are different from those for a consumer brand. The considerations for a regulated industry are different again. A few things worth flagging by context.

For B2B companies, the sales cycle length and the role of marketing in pipeline generation are critical context. An agency that specialises in direct response consumer campaigns may not be the right fit for a company where the average deal takes six months to close and involves five decision-makers. Be explicit about your sales process and how you expect marketing to support it.

For companies in specialist sectors, relevant experience matters more than general capability. If you are in financial services, healthcare, or a technically complex B2B category, an agency that has operated in your space will have a shorter learning curve and a better understanding of the constraints. Marketing for staffing agencies is a good example of a sector where generic digital marketing approaches often underperform because the audience dynamics and conversion economics are specific to the industry.

For smaller businesses, the question of whether a formal RFP process is the right approach at all is worth asking. If you are a small business with a modest budget, a multi-stage RFP process may be more overhead than the decision warrants. A direct conversation with two or three agencies you have identified through referral or research will often produce a better outcome faster. The differences between small business marketing and agency models are worth understanding before you commit to a process designed for enterprise procurement.

When to Include Social Media in Your Digital Marketing RFP

Social media is often included in digital marketing RFPs almost by default, as a line item alongside SEO and paid search. That default assumption is worth challenging. Social media management is operationally intensive in a way that paid search is not. It requires content creation, community management, real-time responsiveness, and platform-specific expertise that varies significantly across channels.

If social is a meaningful part of your scope, consider whether it warrants a separate workstream or even a separate agency relationship. Many companies find that the agency best placed to run their paid search is not the same one best placed to run their social media. Bundling everything into a single RFP can produce a generalist response when what you actually need is a specialist.

If you are considering whether to bring social in-house or keep it with an agency, the decision framework for outsourcing social media marketing covers the trade-offs clearly. It is a more nuanced decision than it is often treated as, and it is worth making it deliberately rather than by default.

The Buffer guide on social media agency operations also gives useful context on how social agencies are structured and what they typically include in their service offering, which helps when you are assessing whether a proposed scope is realistic for the budget.

After the RFP: Making the Final Decision

The formal evaluation process gets you to a shortlist. The final decision is usually made on something harder to score: do you trust these people, do they understand your business, and do you think the working relationship will be productive? Those are legitimate criteria. The best agency relationship I ever had was with a team that did not win on paper but who asked better questions than anyone else in the process. That quality of thinking showed up in everything they did.

Reference checks are underused. Most buyers do them as a formality at the end of the process. They are more useful earlier, when you can still act on what you learn. Ask for references from clients in similar situations to yours, not just the agency’s flagship accounts. Ask those references about the difficult moments, not just the wins. How did the agency behave when a campaign underperformed? How did they handle a disagreement about strategy? Those answers tell you more than the pitch deck ever will.

Contract terms are worth getting right before you start. Scope creep is the single most common source of friction in agency relationships, and it almost always traces back to a contract that was vague about what was and was not included. Be specific about deliverables, reporting cadence, approval processes, and what happens when either party wants to make a change. It is not adversarial to be clear. It is professional.

If you want a broader view of how agencies operate commercially, the Agency Growth & Sales section covers the full landscape, from how agencies structure their services to how they manage client relationships and grow their own businesses. Understanding how your agency thinks about its own commercial model makes you a better client and a better buyer.

About the Author

Keith Lacy is a marketing strategist and former agency CEO with 20+ years of experience across agency leadership, performance marketing, and commercial strategy. He writes The Marketing Juice to cut through the noise and share what works.

Frequently Asked Questions