Competitive Analysis in B2B Digital Marketing: What Most Teams Get Wrong

A competitive analysis in B2B digital marketing is a structured review of how your competitors position themselves, acquire traffic, and engage buyers across digital channels, with the goal of identifying gaps you can exploit and threats you need to anticipate. Done properly, it informs your go-to-market positioning, your channel mix, and your content strategy. Done poorly, it produces a 40-slide deck that nobody acts on.

Most B2B teams do the latter. They pull a few SEMrush screenshots, list competitor taglines, and call it done. What they miss is the strategic layer: understanding not just what competitors are doing, but why, and whether it’s actually working for them.

Why Most B2B Competitive Analyses Fail Before They Start

The problem usually starts with scope. Teams try to analyse everything: every competitor, every channel, every keyword, every piece of content. The output becomes encyclopaedic and operationally useless. Nobody knows what to do with it.

I’ve sat in enough agency strategy sessions to know what happens next. The document gets shared, people nod, and it gets filed somewhere sensible. Three months later, when someone asks how the new campaign is differentiated from what competitors are running, nobody can remember what the analysis actually said.

Effective competitive analysis in B2B digital marketing starts with a question you’re trying to answer, not a template you’re trying to fill. Are you trying to understand why you’re losing search visibility? Are you trying to identify a positioning gap before a product launch? Are you trying to understand where a new entrant is gaining traction? The question shapes the scope. Without it, you’re just collecting information.

If you’re building or refining your broader go-to-market approach, the Go-To-Market and Growth Strategy hub covers the strategic context that competitive analysis should sit inside. Analysis without strategy is just data.

Step 1: Define Your Competitive Set Properly

B2B buyers don’t always buy from who you think your competitors are. Your direct competitors (companies selling the same product to the same buyers) are the obvious starting point. But in digital marketing, you’re also competing with indirect competitors for attention, search visibility, and share of mind.

A useful way to structure this is three tiers. Tier one is direct competitors: same product, same ICP (ideal customer profile), same buying experience. Tier two is indirect competitors: different product, same problem, same buyer. Tier three is content competitors: companies or publications that rank for the same terms and capture your buyers’ attention, even if they’re not selling anything you compete with directly.

When I was running agency new business, we’d often lose pitches not to other agencies but to the client’s internal team building out capability. That’s a competitor. It doesn’t show up in any tool, but it absolutely shapes how you need to position your value. The same logic applies in digital marketing: define competition around buyer behaviour, not just product category.

Limit your active analysis to five to eight competitors maximum. Any more and you lose focus. If you have a longer list, segment them and prioritise the ones most likely to influence your near-term pipeline.

Step 2: Audit Their Digital Presence Systematically

Once you have your competitive set, you need to audit each competitor across the channels that matter for B2B buying decisions. This typically means organic search, paid search, content marketing, LinkedIn, and their website itself (structure, messaging, and conversion approach).

Organic search: Use a tool like SEMrush or Ahrefs to understand which keywords each competitor ranks for, what their estimated organic traffic looks like, and which pages are driving that traffic. Don’t just look at volume. Look at intent. A competitor ranking for high-volume informational terms may be building awareness but not pipeline. A competitor ranking for low-volume, high-intent terms may be capturing buyers at the moment of decision. Those are very different strategies with very different implications for how you compete. SEMrush’s own writing on market penetration strategy is worth reading alongside this, particularly the section on how search visibility maps to market share in established categories.

Paid search: Tools like SEMrush and SpyFu give you a view of competitor paid search activity, including which terms they’re bidding on and what their ad copy looks like. The ad copy is particularly useful. It tells you what message they’re testing, which usually reflects what’s working in their sales conversations. If three of your competitors are all leading with “reduce costs by X%”, that’s a signal about what buyers are responding to. It’s also a signal that leading with the same message will make you invisible.

Content and thought leadership: Review their blog, resource centre, and any gated content you can access. What topics are they covering? What’s the depth and quality? Who is the intended audience? Are they writing for practitioners or for executives? Are they producing content that helps buyers understand their problem, or content that primarily promotes their product? The gap between those two approaches is significant, and it often reveals where a competitor’s content strategy is weak.

LinkedIn: For B2B, LinkedIn is often the primary paid social channel and an important organic channel for thought leadership. Look at competitor company pages, their ad library (LinkedIn’s ad transparency tool shows active ads), and the personal profiles of their senior people. Are their executives posting regularly? Is the company page active? What content formats are they using? LinkedIn engagement data is limited from the outside, but you can get a directional read on what’s resonating.

Website and conversion: Spend time on their website as a buyer would. What’s the primary message above the fold? How do they handle social proof (case studies, logos, testimonials)? What’s their primary conversion mechanism (demo request, free trial, content download)? How long is their navigation? What do they want you to do first? The website structure tells you a lot about how they think about the buying experience and where they’re investing conversion optimisation effort. Tools like Crazy Egg can give you additional context on how behaviour analysis tools are being used in growth contexts, though for competitor analysis you’re primarily working from observation rather than data access.

Step 3: Analyse Messaging and Positioning, Not Just Tactics

This is the step most teams skip or do superficially. They document what competitors say but don’t analyse what it means strategically.

For each competitor, try to articulate their positioning in a single sentence: who they’re for, what problem they solve, and why they’re different. Then look at how consistently that positioning comes through across their website, their ads, their content, and their LinkedIn presence. Inconsistency is a weakness you can exploit. Consistency is a signal they’ve found something that works.

Look specifically at the language they use to describe the problem they solve. B2B buyers often have a vocabulary they use internally to describe their challenges, and the companies that mirror that vocabulary tend to perform better in search and in sales conversations. If your competitors are using different language to describe the same problem, that’s an opportunity to own the terms your buyers actually use.

When I was at iProspect and we were competing for enterprise search mandates, we noticed that most competitors were positioning around technology and scale. We repositioned around commercial accountability: we could show, in detail, how paid search activity connected to revenue outcomes. It wasn’t a new capability. It was a different way of talking about an existing one. That positioning shift came directly from competitive analysis that went beyond “what are they saying” to “what are buyers responding to that nobody is owning yet.”

BCG’s work on brand strategy and go-to-market alignment makes a relevant point here: the companies that win in competitive markets are usually the ones that align their external positioning most tightly with what their buyers actually value, not what the company finds most interesting about itself. Competitive analysis is one of the most reliable ways to identify that gap.

Step 4: Identify Gaps, Not Just Strengths

Most competitive analysis documents tell you what competitors are good at. That’s useful context. But the commercially valuable output is the gap map: where are buyers underserved, where is the conversation thin, where is nobody showing up?

In organic search, gaps show up as keyword clusters with meaningful search volume and weak or low-quality ranking content. If your competitors are ranking for a topic but their content is shallow, that’s an opportunity to outrank them by going deeper. If nobody is ranking well for a topic your buyers are searching, that’s a creation opportunity.

In content and thought leadership, gaps often appear at the edges of the topic. Most B2B content clusters around the same core questions. The gaps are usually in the more specific, more advanced, or more adjacent questions that buyers have once they’ve moved past the basics. If you can identify what your buyers are asking that nobody is answering well, you have a content strategy.

In paid search, gaps appear in terms that have buyer intent but low competition. These are often longer-tail terms, comparison terms (“X vs Y”), or category terms that competitors haven’t bid on. In the early days of paid search, before the channel became as competitive as it is now, finding these gaps was relatively straightforward. I ran a campaign at lastminute.com for a music festival where the keyword landscape was essentially uncontested, and we generated six figures of revenue in roughly a day from a campaign that took an afternoon to build. The channel is more mature now, but the principle still applies: the gaps are where the value is, not the obvious terms where everyone is already fighting.

Forrester’s research on intelligent growth models makes a point that’s relevant here: sustainable competitive advantage in digital channels comes from identifying and occupying positions that are structurally difficult for competitors to replicate, not from outspending them on the same terms.

Step 5: Assess Their Buyer experience, Not Just Their Channels

B2B buying is rarely a single-channel, single-touchpoint process. A buyer might find a competitor through organic search, follow them on LinkedIn for three months, download a report, and then request a demo. Understanding how competitors structure that experience gives you a clearer picture of where they’re investing and where they’re leaving buyers without support.

Walk through their buyer experience as a prospect would. Search for a problem-aware term and see if they appear. Visit their site and note what they ask you to do. Sign up for their email list and observe the nurture sequence. Request a demo or a piece of gated content and see how they follow up. This takes time, but it gives you ground-level intelligence that no tool can provide.

Pay particular attention to how they handle the middle of the funnel. Most B2B digital marketing is reasonably competent at the top (awareness content, SEO) and the bottom (demo pages, pricing pages). The middle, where buyers are evaluating options and building internal consensus, is where most teams are weakest. If your competitors are weak there too, that’s where you build.

Vidyard’s research on pipeline and revenue potential for GTM teams highlights how much pipeline value is lost in the middle of the funnel when buyers don’t get the content and engagement they need to move forward. If your competitors aren’t addressing this well, it’s a meaningful opportunity.

Step 6: Layer in Qualitative Intelligence

Tools give you data. Data gives you a hypothesis. Qualitative intelligence tells you whether the hypothesis is right.

The best sources of qualitative competitive intelligence in B2B are your own sales team, your customers, and review platforms. Your sales team hears competitor names in every discovery call and knows which objections are competitor-driven. Your customers chose you over someone else and can usually tell you why, if you ask directly. Review platforms like G2 and Capterra contain detailed, unfiltered buyer opinions about competitor products, which is some of the most useful competitive intelligence available and almost nobody mines it systematically.

I’ve seen agencies spend significant budget on competitive research tools and ignore the fact that their own account managers were sitting on a goldmine of competitive intelligence from client conversations. The tools are useful. But they’re a starting point, not the whole picture.

One specific tactic: read the negative reviews of your competitors on G2 or Capterra. Not to gloat, but to understand the recurring friction points that buyers experience. If multiple reviews mention that a competitor’s onboarding is complex, or that their support is slow, or that the reporting is opaque, those are positioning opportunities for you, and they’re grounded in real buyer experience rather than your own assumptions.

Step 7: Turn the Analysis into Decisions

This is where most competitive analysis fails to deliver value. The research is done, the gaps are identified, and then nothing changes. The analysis doesn’t connect to a decision.

Every competitive analysis should end with a short list of specific actions: a positioning statement to test, a keyword cluster to build content around, a channel to enter or exit, a message to retire because three competitors are already using it. If you can’t articulate what you’re going to do differently as a result of the analysis, the analysis wasn’t sharp enough.

BCG’s work on scaling agile approaches is instructive here, even if the context is different. The principle of moving from insight to action quickly, rather than letting analysis become a substitute for decision-making, applies directly to competitive intelligence work. The market doesn’t wait for your deck to be finished.

A practical format: for each major finding, write one sentence describing what you observed, one sentence explaining what it means strategically, and one sentence describing the specific action it implies. That structure forces you to connect observation to implication to decision. It also makes the output far more useful for the people who need to act on it.

How Often Should You Run a Competitive Analysis?

In B2B digital marketing, the competitive landscape shifts faster than most quarterly planning cycles account for. New entrants appear. Established players change their messaging. Someone raises a round and doubles their paid search budget. A content strategy that was working six months ago may be fully replicated by three competitors today.

A full competitive analysis, covering all the steps above, makes sense at major inflection points: before a product launch, before entering a new market, before a significant budget increase, or when you notice a meaningful shift in your own performance metrics that you can’t explain internally. That’s typically two to four times a year for most B2B marketing teams.

Between full analyses, build a lighter monitoring process. Set up Google Alerts for competitor names. Follow their LinkedIn pages. Check their ad library monthly. Review their blog for new topic areas. This takes an hour or two a month and keeps you from being surprised by a significant shift in their strategy.

The teams I’ve seen do this well treat competitive intelligence as an ongoing input to their strategy, not a periodic project. It informs their content calendar, their paid search bidding, their sales enablement, and their positioning work continuously. That’s a very different operating model from the “let’s do a competitive audit” approach that produces a document nobody reads.

Competitive analysis is one input into a broader growth strategy. If you’re thinking about how all the pieces connect, from positioning to channel selection to demand generation, the Go-To-Market and Growth Strategy hub covers the full picture.

About the Author

Keith Lacy is a marketing strategist and former agency CEO with 20+ years of experience across agency leadership, performance marketing, and commercial strategy. He writes The Marketing Juice to cut through the noise and share what works.

Frequently Asked Questions