One SEO Strategy Does Not Fit All Business Models

A good agency does not apply the same SEO framework to every client. The approach that works for a national e-commerce retailer looks almost nothing like what a local service business or a B2B SaaS company needs. Business model, sales cycle, margin structure, and customer intent all shape what good SEO actually looks like in practice.

Custom SEO strategy starts with understanding how a business makes money, not with a keyword tool. Agencies that skip this step tend to produce technically competent work that generates traffic with no commercial value. The business model is the brief.

Why Business Model Has to Come Before Keyword Research

I have sat in enough new business meetings to know the pattern. Agency presents a keyword opportunity report. Client sees large search volumes. Everyone gets excited. Six months later, the traffic is up and the revenue is flat. The keywords were real. The intent was wrong.

The fundamental question any agency should ask before touching a keyword tool is: how does this business actually generate revenue? Not what does it sell, but how does the commercial model work? A business selling high-ticket B2B software with a six-month sales cycle needs SEO that supports education and trust-building across a long funnel. A business selling consumable products with a two-minute checkout needs SEO that captures transactional intent at the moment someone is ready to buy. These are not variations on a theme. They are different problems requiring different solutions.

When I was running iProspect, we worked across more than thirty industries simultaneously. The thing that separated the accounts that performed from the ones that flatlined was almost never technical SEO quality. It was whether the strategy was built around how the client’s customers actually bought, rather than around what was easiest to optimise for. Getting that right required understanding the business model before writing a single brief.

If you want a broader framework for how SEO strategy should be structured from the ground up, the Complete SEO Strategy hub covers the full picture, including how to align channel work to commercial goals rather than channel-specific metrics.

How Local Businesses Need SEO to Work Differently

Local SEO is not a simplified version of national SEO. It is a different discipline with different signals, different competitive dynamics, and a different relationship between search and conversion.

For a local service business, a plumber, a dental practice, a solicitor, the geography is the product. Someone searching for an emergency plumber in Manchester does not want the best plumber in the country. They want someone who can be there in two hours. The entire SEO strategy has to be built around that proximity and urgency. That means Google Business Profile optimisation, local citation consistency, review acquisition, and content that signals genuine local relevance rather than keyword stuffing a location name into a generic page.

Wistia has a useful piece on using Google Business Profile video to strengthen local SEO, which is a good example of how local signals extend beyond just text-based content. The local search ecosystem rewards businesses that look genuinely active and present in their community, not just technically optimised.

What I see agencies get wrong with local clients is applying a content volume strategy that makes no sense for the business. A local accountancy firm does not need fifty blog posts about general tax topics. It needs a well-structured site, a strong Google Business Profile, consistent NAP data across directories, and content that answers the specific questions its local clients are actually asking. The strategy should be narrow and deep, not broad and thin.

HubSpot’s overview of small business SEO fundamentals makes a similar point: for smaller businesses, focus and execution beat comprehensive strategy every time. Trying to compete on every front simultaneously is how small businesses burn budget without seeing returns.

What E-Commerce SEO Actually Requires

E-commerce SEO has a structural complexity that most other business models do not. When you have thousands of product pages, category pages, and faceted navigation, the technical layer becomes genuinely important. Crawl budget, indexation, duplicate content from filter parameters, and page speed all matter in ways that they simply do not for a ten-page service business site.

But the strategic layer matters just as much. E-commerce SEO lives or dies on understanding the purchase funnel. Someone searching “best running shoes for flat feet” is in a different mental state to someone searching “Nike React Infinity Run Flyknit 4 size 10.” Both are valuable. Neither should be treated the same way. The first needs content that educates and builds trust. The second needs a product page that is fast, clear, and converts.

Semrush’s breakdown of how SEO works across different business contexts touches on this distinction between informational and transactional intent, which is the core tension in e-commerce SEO strategy. Getting the balance right requires understanding the margin structure of the product range, not just the search volume of the keywords.

I have seen e-commerce accounts where the agency had driven significant traffic growth to category pages that had almost no conversion rate, while the high-intent product pages with real commercial value were barely optimised. The reporting looked good. The business results did not. That is what happens when strategy is built around what is easy to move rather than what matters to the business.

B2B SEO Is a Long Game With a Different Scoreboard

B2B SEO is where the mismatch between agency metrics and business outcomes tends to be most pronounced. The sales cycles are long, the buying committees are large, and the conversion events that actually matter, a qualified demo request, a signed proposal, a contract, happen weeks or months after the first search interaction.

If an agency is reporting on organic traffic and keyword rankings for a B2B client with a six-month sales cycle, they are reporting on the wrong things. The question is not how many people visited the site. The question is whether the right people visited, whether the content gave them enough confidence to engage, and whether the pipeline has moved as a result. Those are harder questions to answer, which is exactly why most agencies avoid them.

B2B SEO strategy should be built around the buying experience, not the search funnel. That means content that addresses the specific concerns of each stakeholder in the buying committee, not just the person who does the initial search. A procurement manager, a technical lead, and a CFO all have different questions about the same product. The SEO strategy needs to account for all of them.

Moz’s analysis of where SEO is heading makes the point that search is increasingly about demonstrating genuine expertise and authority, not just technical optimisation. For B2B businesses, this is an opportunity. Depth of knowledge is a competitive advantage that large, generic content farms cannot replicate. A specialist B2B company that publishes genuinely expert content has a natural edge, if the agency is smart enough to build a strategy around it.

SaaS SEO Has Its Own Commercial Logic

SaaS businesses have a recurring revenue model, which changes the economics of SEO significantly. Customer acquisition cost matters, but so does the lifetime value of the customer you acquire. A SaaS company paying to acquire a customer who churns in three months has a very different problem to one acquiring customers who stay for three years. SEO strategy needs to account for this.

The best SaaS SEO strategies I have seen are built around the product itself. They target the problems the product solves, the alternatives it competes with, and the workflows it fits into. This is sometimes called product-led SEO, and it works because the content is genuinely useful to the people most likely to become customers. It is not content marketing for its own sake. It is content that maps directly to purchase intent.

Comparison and alternative pages are a good example. Someone searching “Salesforce alternatives for small business” is in a buying mindset. They know they have a problem and they are evaluating solutions. A SaaS company that appears for that search with a well-structured, honest comparison page is not just generating traffic. It is intercepting a qualified buyer at exactly the right moment. That is the kind of SEO that moves revenue, not just rankings.

Buffer has written about DIY SEO approaches for smaller businesses, which is a useful perspective on how businesses with limited resources can still build a focused strategy. The principle applies to early-stage SaaS companies too: doing a few things well beats doing everything poorly.

Travel and Hospitality: When Seasonality Shapes Everything

Travel businesses have a seasonal demand curve that most other industries do not, and that curve has to be baked into the SEO strategy from the start. Building content in October for searches that peak in January is not optional. It is the minimum viable approach.

Ahrefs has a useful breakdown of SEO specifically for travel agencies, which covers the interplay between seasonal content, destination pages, and the kind of long-tail queries that signal genuine booking intent. The travel sector is also one where user-generated content and reviews carry significant weight in both search rankings and conversion. A strategy that ignores this is missing a substantial part of the picture.

The competitive dynamics in travel SEO are also worth noting. The major OTAs and booking platforms have enormous domain authority and content budgets. A boutique travel agency trying to compete on generic destination terms is fighting a battle it cannot win. The smarter approach is to go narrower: specialist itineraries, niche destinations, specific traveller profiles. The search volumes are smaller but the intent is sharper and the competition is thinner.

The Process a Good Agency Actually Follows

When an agency is doing this properly, the strategy development process looks roughly like this.

First, they spend real time understanding the business model. Not a thirty-minute onboarding call. A genuine commercial conversation about how the business makes money, who the best customers are, what the sales cycle looks like, and where SEO fits in the broader acquisition mix. This is not glamorous work, but it is the work that determines whether the strategy will be useful or just technically competent.

Second, they map the customer experience. Not the idealised version from a marketing textbook, but the actual path that real customers take from first awareness to purchase. This usually involves talking to the client’s sales team, looking at CRM data, and understanding what questions come up repeatedly in the buying process. Those questions are the foundation of a content strategy that actually supports commercial outcomes.

Third, they do the keyword and competitive research in the context of what they have already learned. The keyword tool comes third, not first. This sounds obvious. It is not how most agencies work.

Fourth, they build a prioritisation framework that accounts for commercial value, not just search volume. A keyword with five hundred monthly searches that maps directly to a high-margin product is worth more than a keyword with fifty thousand searches that attracts people who will never buy. Agencies that optimise for volume over value are optimising for their own reporting, not the client’s business.

Fifth, they set measurement frameworks that connect SEO activity to business outcomes. Organic traffic is a leading indicator. Revenue, pipeline contribution, and customer acquisition cost are the metrics that matter. If the agency cannot connect its work to those numbers, it is operating without accountability.

The broader point here is that custom SEO strategy is not about doing more. It is about doing the right things for the specific commercial context. For a more detailed look at how all of this fits together, the Complete SEO Strategy hub covers the full range of strategic and tactical considerations, from technical foundations to content planning to measurement.

What to Look for When Evaluating an Agency’s Approach

If you are assessing whether an agency is genuinely building a custom strategy or applying a template with your logo on it, there are a few straightforward tests.

Ask them to explain their strategy in terms of your business model, not in terms of SEO mechanics. If they can tell you clearly why a particular approach makes sense given how your business generates revenue, that is a good sign. If they default to explaining domain authority and keyword difficulty, that is not a strategy conversation. That is a channel conversation.

Ask what success looks like in twelve months. Not in terms of rankings or traffic, but in terms of business outcomes. A good agency should be able to describe what commercial progress looks like and how they will know if the work is contributing to it. Vague answers here are a warning sign.

Ask how the strategy would change if your business model changed. If the answer is “we would update the keyword list,” the strategy is not really custom. A genuinely tailored approach is built on commercial logic that would shift meaningfully if the business shifted.

I have judged the Effie Awards, which recognises marketing effectiveness rather than creative quality. The work that wins is almost always work where the strategy was built around a specific commercial problem rather than a generic channel opportunity. SEO is no different. The best results come from strategies that are honest about what the business needs, not from agencies that are good at packaging generic work as bespoke solutions.

Moz’s look at the intersection of algorithm behaviour and content strategy is a useful reminder that the platforms and signals are always shifting, which makes the commercial grounding of a strategy even more important. Tactics change. The business model does not.

About the Author

Keith Lacy is a marketing strategist and former agency CEO with 20+ years of experience across agency leadership, performance marketing, and commercial strategy. He writes The Marketing Juice to cut through the noise and share what works.

Frequently Asked Questions